EXCLUSIVE: The FINAL 2025 QB RANKINGS are a DAMNING INDICTMENT of the NFL’s broken system, exposing MULTIPLE FRANCHISE-SHATTERING BUSTS and a league in FULL-BLOWN CRISIS. Forget stats—this is a CATACLYSMIC EVALUATION of wasted talent and stolen billions.
We rank them NOW not on potential, but on their PATHETIC, season-long FAILURES. The results will SHOCK you and expose the LIES your team has been selling.
TIER 6: NOT STARTING CALIBER – A GRAVEYARD OF BROKEN DREAMS. The New York Jets’ experiment with a STEELERS CASTOFF is a NIGHTMARE, proving the front office is CLUELESS. In Minnesota, J.J. McCarthy isn’t just a disappointment—he’s a FRAUD, already slated to be DUMPED for a veteran. And Tua Tagovailoa? His concussion history is a TICKING TIME BOMB; betting on his future is MORALLY BANKRUPT.
TIER 5: FLASHING? MORE LIKE CRASHING. Michael Penix Jr.’s injuries may have ended his career BEFORE IT STARTED. In Cleveland, Shedeur Sanders is a HOSTAGE to the Deshaun Watson contract, doomed to fail without support. Kyler Murray? ABANDONED by Arizona. His $230 million extension is the WORST CONTRACT IN SPORTS HISTORY.
THE TRUE SCANDAL lies in Tier 4, where “clear starters” like Baker Mayfield and Jayden Daniels have GLARING, CAREER-KILLING FLAWS. Mayfield’s late-game MELTDOWNS have the Bucs in a tailspin, while Daniels’ injury-plagued season screams “RG3 DISASTER 2.0.” These aren’t quarterbacks; they are LIABILITIES.
Even the so-called “ELITE” are EXPOSED. Patrick Mahomes, the “best in the NFL,” looked MORTAL without help, while Joe Burrow ROTS in the “football prison” of Cincinnati. Lamar Jackson is at war with his own franchise. The system is DESIGNED TO CRUSH greatness.
At the top, Drake Maye’s MVP-caliber season in New England is a MIRAGE built on smoke and mirrors, a fleeting brilliance that highlights how EVERYONE ELSE HAS FAILED. The evidence is undeniable: the quarterback position, and the league that depends on it, is hurtling toward a DARK AND UNFIXABLE ABYSS.
